Sitemaps
Should Kids Follow in Our Founder Footsteps?
The Evolution of Entry Level Workers
Assume Everyone Will Leave in Year One
Stop Listening to Investors
Was Mortgaging My Life Worth it?
What's My Startup Worth in an Acquisition?
When Our Ambition is Our Enemy
Are Startups in a "Silent Recession"?
The 5 Types of Startup Funding
What Is Startup Funding?
Do Founders Deserve Their Profit?
Michelle Glauser on Diversity and Inclusion
The Utter STUPIDITY of "Risking it All"
Committees Are Where Progress Goes to Die
More Money (Really Means) More Problems
Why Most Founders Don't Get Rich
Investors will be Obsolete
Why is a Founder so Hard to Replace?
We Can't Grow by Saying "No"
Do People Really Want Me to Succeed?
Is the Problem the Player or the Coach?
Will Investors Bail Me Out?
The Value of Actually Getting Paid
Why do Founders Suck at Asking for Help?
Wait a Minute before Giving Away Equity
You Only Think You Work Hard
SMALL is the New Big — Embracing Efficiency in the Age of AI
The 9 Best Growth Agencies for Startups
This is BOOTSTRAPPED — 3 Strategies to Build Your Startup Without Funding
Never Share Your Net Worth
A Steady Hand in the Middle of the Storm
Risk it All vs Steady Paycheck
How About a Startup that Just Makes Money?
How to Recruit a Rockstar Advisor
Why Having Zero Experience is a Huge Asset
My Competitor Got Funded — Am I Screwed?
The Hidden Treasure of Failed Startups
If It Makes Money, It Makes Sense
Why do VCs Keep Giving Failed Founders Money?
$10K Per Month isn't Just Revenue — It's Life Support
The Ridiculous Spectrum of Investor Feedback
Startup CEOs Aren't Really CEOs
Series A, B, C, D, and E Funding: How It Works
Best Pitch Decks Ever: The Most Successful Fundraising Pitches You Need to Know
When to Raise Funds
Why Aren't Investors Responding to Me?
Should I Regret Not Raising Capital?
Unemployment Cases — Why I LOOOOOVE To Win Them So Much.
How Much to Pay Yourself
Heat-Seeking Missile: WePay’s Journey to Product-Market Fit — Interview with Rich Aberman, Co-Founder of Wepay
The R&D technique for startups: Rip off & Duplicate
Why Some Startups Win.
Chapter #1: First Steps To Validate Your Business Idea
Product Users, Not Ideas, Will Determine Your Startup’s Fate
Drop Your Free Tier
Your Advisors Are Probably Wrong
Growth Isn't Always Good
How to Shut Down Gracefully
How Does My Startup Get Acquired?
Can Entrepreneurship Be Taught?
How to Pick the Wrong Co-Founder
Staying Small While Going Big
Investors are NOT on Our Side of the Table
Who am I Really Competing Against?
Why Can't Founders Replace Themselves?
Actually, We Have Plenty of Time
Quitting vs Letting Go
How Startups Actually Get Bought
What if I'm Building the Wrong Product?
Are Founders Driven by Fear or Greed?
Why I'm Either Working or Feeling Guilty
Startup Financial Assumptions
Why Every Kid Should be a Startup Founder
We Only Have to be Right Once
If a Startup Sinks, Founders Go Down With it
Founder Success: We Need a Strict Definition of Personal Success
Is Quiet Quitting a Problem at Startup Companies?
Founder Exits are Hard Work and Good Fortune, Not "Good Luck"
Finalizing Startup Projections
All Founders are Beloved In Good Times
Our Startup Culture of Entitlement
The Bullshit Case for Raising Capital
How do We Manage Our Founder Flaws?
What If my plan for retirement is "never retire"?
Startup Failure is just One Chapter in Founder Life
6 Similarities between Startup Founders and Pro Athletes
All Founders Make Bad Decisions — and That's OK
Startup Board Negotiations: How do I tell the board I need a new deal?
Founder Sacrifice — At What Point Have I Gone Too Far?
Youth Entrepreneurship: Can Middle Schoolers be Founders?
Living the Founder Legend Isn't so Fun
Why Do VC Funded Startups Love "Fake Growth?"
How Should I Share My Wealth with Family?
How Many Deaths Can a Startup Survive?
This is Probably Your Last Success
Why Do We Still Have Full-Time Employees?
The Case Against Full Transparency
Should I Feel Guilty for Failing?
Always Take Money off the Table
Founder Impostor Syndrome Never Goes Away

The Ridiculous Spectrum of Investor Feedback

Wil Schroter

The Ridiculous Spectrum of Investor Feedback

How do you know if the advice you just got from an investor on your fundraise was any good?

(Spoiler: it's probably terrible advice, and you're about to waste a lot of time following it.)

We review thousands of pitch decks at Startups.com, and as part of that process, we hear countless tales of Founders having gotten "really strong advice" from an investor they talked with about their deal. They get super hung up on changing everything to accommodate this feedback.

My question is always, "Who was the investor, and what were their qualifications to give that advice?"

Whenever I ask, the Founder says "Well... they are an INVESTOR!" as if claiming that title is tantamount to irrefutable knowledge. Look, I invest in the stock market, but that doesn't make me Warren Buffet, and you should absolutely not take my advice on stock picking, no matter how junior you are!

They are All on the Spectrum

For those unfamiliar with the massively broad spectrum of investors, let me first start by saying, well, it's a massive spectrum. Most of us don't spend time with lots of investors, so we can't tell the difference, but the difference is incredible because they all have a significant bias toward their own backgrounds and needs.

Let's start by defining both ends of the spectrum. On the left side of the spectrum are your "most prominent venture capitalists" like Sequoia, Andreessen Horowitz, and Kleiner Perkins. When they review our pitch decks, the feedback they will give will be based on their needs rather than ours. They will tell us that this needs to be a multi-billion dollar opportunity, and we will need to raise hundreds of millions of dollars. And they are right — if we raise from them (which there's a 99% statistical chance we will not).

On the right side of the spectrum is your rich uncle who made all his money in real estate in the 1970's. He will tell you that you need to be seeking profit in year one, that you should be talking about how you'll deliver an Invested Rate of Return (IRR), and that you should also consider talking to a bank. And he would be totally right — if we were opening up a bakery in 1978.

How to Tell Who's Who

You don't actually need to know precisely where everyone lands, you just need to know that the likelihood that the person giving you advice is well-aligned with your particular fundraise is probably low. That only means that while getting feedback is good, we have to calibrate that feedback to the source. The first step is simply asking the question, "How does their experience sync with my opportunity?"

Here's an example: A Founder tells me that a local investor has told them that their valuation is way too high. I have the same battery of questions every time:

  1. "Do you know how many investments this investor has made in startups in the last 3 years?" What I'm really asking is, "Is this person a professional investor who does this for a living, or are they just someone who writes a check every now and again?" Because if they aren't active in the investing scene, their information on current valuations is likely wrong.

  2. "Have you gotten this same feedback from multiple investors or just this one?" As Founders, we're looking for trends, not blips. Any one investor can make an outrageous suggestion in a vacuum that no other investor would corroborate. Every investor has a bias, and going all in on one person's bias is dangerous as hell.

  3. "What do you think makes this investor qualified to give you advice on your specific fundraise?" Of all the questions, this is the one that stumps most Founders. It didn't even occur to me to ask this question in my first 20 years of being a Founder, so I get it. The reality is, that when giving advice, investors rarely get pre-qualified. It's like saying you'll write a check instantly makes all your crazy-ass feedback credible. It does not.

Even just asking these questions will put most Founders ahead of 90% of their peers when receiving feedback. Even if we don't entirely know the answers, a healthy bit of skepticism is in order.

The Fatal Path of Bad Advice

I bring up this spectrum because my fellow Founders don't take all investor feedback as gospel and blindly change their business model, pitch deck, or focus based on a single thread of feedback. It happens so often that I can't even wrap my head around the scope of it.

9 times out of 10, when we unpack the advice a Founder has just gotten, the outcome is, "Holy hell, that would have been the wrong path!" That's not because the advice itself was "bad" (always well-intentioned). It's that it's rarely well-suited to the Founder's actual situation. So be careful, friends.

When it comes to advice, I'll leave you with the same advice I gave to my son the day he was born in a long letter that I wrote him. I wrote to him: "Question everyone - even me" so he would never take anyone's statements for granted. I'm sure when he becomes a teenager I'll regret every word of that, but I have to say — it's served his old man awfully well, and I think it will serve you well too.

Don’t miss out on free credits from Google Cloud for Startups! It’s your chance to leverage powerful cloud solutions without the initial cost. Click here to get started and propel your startup forward.

In Case You Missed It

If We Want Power, Create Power (podcast) A lot of us are used to hearing people telling us what we should and shouldn’t do, what we can and cannot achieve just because these people have tried it or have been in a similar situation. What they don’t realize though is what works for them may not work for you, and vice versa.

Startup Culture is a Reflection of the Founder Everything you do has implications and if you let instigators of negativity be, you’re allowing a nasty culture to spread.

Startup CEOs Aren't Really CEOs The CEO title bears a lot of responsibility. It’s easy to get the title anyone can become one — but do you have the right qualifications and enough experience to be called a CEO?

Find this article helpful?

This is just a small sample! Register to unlock our in-depth courses, hundreds of video courses, and a library of playbooks and articles to grow your startup fast. Let us Let us show you!

Submission confirms agreement to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Already a member? Login

No comments yet.

Register to join the discussion.

Already a member? Login

Create Free Account