This will be the very first kind of money that we getting from investors besides what the founders put in. What are the legal rules as far as accredited and unaccredited investors, minimum and maximum investment? Any advice about pitfalls and steps to take so that if everything goes wrong, the relationships will survive?
You may find this article helpful: http://www.smarthustle.com/article/how-5-smart-hustlers-found-money-for-their-startups/
In short, one entrepreneur, who was looking to borrow money, founded TrustLeaf as he was encountering exactly this question and found no good solution. His new company now helps others gracefully, legally and safely borrow money from friends and family.
Answered 8 years ago
Your team's sense of the long run value of the relationships augurs well for your success. So I trust that the know your self know the other advice leverages that for you.
If at all possible raise money by selling a customer a product or a service. Second, try non-equity crowd funding, preselling your product as did Pebble provides a sound way to obtain cash. If you fail to raise the minimum amount of funds they will be returned; relationships preserved.
If you are going to raise funds from angels, who under securities legislation are likely to be accredited investors, first demonstrate to yourself that you (a) will be able to generate enough high margin ales three years after you receive the funds that you will be able to pay the angels as much as they advanced and continue to do so for twenty-four more years; and (b) you and your team mates will collectively have at least as much in your jeans from the business as the angels get. if you cannot satisfy yourselves of this do not waste your time and that of angels by asking them for money. Either change your business model or sell something to somebody.
A good way to start the process is to profile your business with the highly regards Critical Factors Assessment; profile yourselves as individuals; and imagine asking your Grandfather for money based on the feedback from the profiles.
Answered 8 years ago
As a UK entrepreneur where this stuff has totally different (i.e. relaxed) rules, I can't comment on the specifics there.
However, as someone who has taken early 'angel' money from friends I can give this advice:
1) Keep it as separated from your personal relationship as possible. This means making repayments on time (if it's a loan) and doing realistic and fair equity deals.
2) Create a basic written agreement - you probably don't need to use professionals yet. Stick to the important details and keep a copy each. Any good lawyer can turn something written on the back of a napkin into a legally binding contract, so don't worry about that for now. Make an agreement and if the company becomes worth anything, you can spend some money to redraft that agreement if needed.
3) Make sure everyone is totally clear that as soon as the money is handed over, there's a 90% chance it's gone already. Don't make any promises to "personally repay every penny if it doesn't work out" because thats not how business works. Treat your friends/family with professional respect and trust that they fully understand the risks of investing or borrowing to startups.
4) Be transparant with them on progress, so any bad news doesn't arrive suddenly. In the 90% chance that it burns and you lose all of their money, you need to be able to repair your relationship afterwards and that will be a lot easier if they've been with you on the journey
I borrowed money from friends as loan capital on 2 occasions, and on both occasions was fortunate enough to have everything work out great and I repaid the money with a great return.
Happy to talk further over a call on handling this as an entrepreneur.
Answered 8 years ago
I would definitely only sell stock to accredited investors. I would also get a written document from the attesting to the fact that they are accredited (these forms should be available on the internet). Not aware of any minimum or maximum investment amount, but you need to file a Form D with the SEC, stating that you are doing a private offering that is exempt from normal SEC Reporting. You really should discuss this with a business attorney who does this type of work before you do anything.
As for pitfalls, be upfront with them and let them know that their investment will be at risk. Never EVER promise a sure thing. I would tell them that if they don't have "extra" money to invest that they should not do it. Make sure you have everything in writing and do the transaction with them just like you would do with someone you don't know.
If you treat is as a business transaction and are upfront about the risks you should avoid any problems.
Answered 8 years ago
(I am not a lawyer, nothing here is legal advice, if you are unsure, consult a lawyer, blah blah. But I have built and sold two businesses, and raised money initially from friends & family in both cases.)
I'd echo what Liam has said: draw up a simple agreement to make sure everyone understands what is agreed. I've several times seen casual agreements completely misunderstood by the two parties later on. Writing it down makes you think it through, and makes sure everyone is (literally) on the same page.
The most basic misunderstanding is whether the money is equity (a share of the business, so investors may get many multiples of their money back if the business succeeds, but zero if the business fails) or debt (investors get their money back plus agreed interest if the business succeeds, but zero if the business fails).
For example, I know of two family situations where someone gave a family member money to help them buy a house. Recipient thought the money was a loan. “Lender” thought they were getting a share of the house. Move forward 5 years and the recipient wants to sell the house and pay back the family loan. The lender thinks they own 20% of the house, though, and are expecting to get their share of the house when it is sold. Big difference.
From your (business owner’s) point of view, debt is usually cheaper than equity (you only pay back some fixed interest, not a whole chunk of your entire business); but most investors would sensibly expect their investment to be an equity investment (if they risk losing all their money, they should reasonably expect a big return if things go well).
(It is possible to do both, with a convertible loan, incidentally. This is where your investor puts money in as a loan, and if you later raise more investment that loan money converts into equity at the same valuation as the new money coming in. For example, someone lends you $50k. Some time later you raise $500k at a $2.5m valuation, so that $50k loan turns into 2% of the company (50k / $2.5m = 2%). In practice, you’d agree in advance some discounted valuation to convert the loan into equity. So, given that the early investor has taken more risk, maybe you set their valuation at 50% of what the new money gets. So $50k / $1.25m = 4%, the original lender gets 4%.
The main advantage of a convertible loan is it is quicker and easier to draft than a full-on shareholder's agreement. And you don’t need to agree a valuation for the business until later. This is especially important if local regulations prohibit you from just winging it with a back-of-a-napkin agreement. There’s a good summary here from Mark Suster about how convertible loans work: http://www.bothsidesofthetable.com/2010/08/30/is-convertible-debt-preferable-to-equity/)
But if you can agree a valuation, and your investors (and regulators) are friendly/relaxed enough to tolerate a very simple shareholders’ agreement, you could just write it yourself. I have a standard one-page document which I’ve used for friends & family rounds at my last two businesses, and it just covers four things: drag-along, tag-along, pre-emption and not-unreasonable salary.
Drag-along means that if someone else offers to buy your shares, you can force the other shareholders to sell on the same terms (as the buyer will likely want 100%, you need to be sure you can deliver them 100%, even if your other shareholders no longer like you / are uncontactable / etc.). My standard document just says this:
"If a bona fide arms-length offer is made to purchase all of the Company’s shares, and that offer is accepted by Shareholders holding a majority of the shares, all Shareholders shall be obliged to sell their shares on the offered terms so long as the terms represent no less than fair market value."
(The bit about bona-fide offer and ‘no less than fair market value’ is intended to stop you selling the whole company to your wife for $1 and wiping out the minority shareholders)
Tag-along means that if someone offers to buy the majority of the company, they have to buy all of it (so that your minority shareholders aren’t left holding some tiny percentage of a company now controlled by someone else and they never get to sell). My home-made document covers this in one clause:
"A sale or transfer of a majority of the Company’s shares may only be made if the proposed transferee has offered to acquire all of the Company’s Shares"
Pre-emption means that your early investors have the right to participate in any later funding rounds, on the same terms as the new investors, in order to maintain their same percentage share of the business. My standard document says this:
"No new shares shall be issued unless they have first been offered to the Shareholders in such proportions as to allow them to maintain their pro-rata shareholding after the new share issue."
Not-unreasonable salary means that you (being director and majority shareholder) can’t siphon off all the profits by paying yourself a massive salary, leaving nothing for the shareholders. You agree to only pay yourself maximum of a reasonable market salary.
Those are, in my experience, the key things which will crop up further down the line and should be agreed up front. If you get to the point where you are taking professional investment, you’ll end up with a 50-page shareholders’ agreement covering a gazillion other things. But for friends & family, those are the key issues that I would suggest you decide on and write down.
Answered 8 years ago